If you're considering bringing the arcade experience home, you're likely comparing full-featured cabinets like the AtGames Legends Ultimate (ALU) with more focused units such as those from Arcade1Up. Here's what sets them apart:
Library & Expandability
AtGames Legends Ultimate
Comes with 300–350 licensed arcade and console games built in.(PCMag, in.ign.com, WIRED)
Offers ArcadeNet streaming, BYOG™ (Bring Your Own Game), and USB/HDMI ports for adding games or connecting external devices.(atgames.net, 9to5Toys, WIRED)
Called a “modder’s dream” by How-To Geek for easy expansion and customization.(How-To Geek)
Arcade1Up
Usually includes 3–12 games tied to specific franchises.(Popular Mechanics, How-To Geek)
Limited official expansion—modding is possible but not supported natively.
Verdict: ALU offers deep expandability, while Arcade1Up focuses on themed simplicity.
Build Quality & Controls
AtGames Legends Ultimate
Full-size cabinet built from heavy MDF (approx. 66 inches tall).(PCMag, uk.pcmag.com)
High-quality controls: two joysticks, six buttons per player, spinners, and a trackball. Reviewers praise the smooth feel and versatility.(The Gamer, How-To Geek)
Arcade1Up
Compact ¾-scale cabinets (around 45 inches tall).(PCMag, uk.pcmag.com)
Controls are simpler and less custom-critical, geared toward accessibility.
Verdict: ALU delivers arcade-grade controls in a full-sized cabinet. Arcade1Up opts for convenience and space-saving.
Assembly & Ease of Use
AtGames Legends Ultimate
Top half arrives preassembled. Setup takes around 30–60 minutes.(PCMag, How-To Geek)
A little heavier and top-heavy, so anchor is recommended.(PCMag)
Arcade1Up
Simpler assembly but requires full construction. Often quicker and manageable for one person.
Verdict: ALU’s modular assembly makes it approachable despite the size; Arcade1Up is lighter and even quicker to set up.
Connectivity & Features
AtGames Legends Ultimate
Offers Wi-Fi, firmware updates, streaming, leaderboards, and developer SDK.(atgames.net, WIRED, prweb.com)
Supports HDMI and USB attachments for external gaming, making it versatile.(atgames.net, WIRED)
Arcade1Up
More limited: typically focused on standalone gameplay without online features.
Verdict: ALU is feature-rich and modern; Arcade1Up keeps it simple.
Real User Feedback
From Reddit discussions:
"If you only have room in your space for one cabinet then go with Legends Ultimate… more capable and includes impressive control deck… but menu navigation can be overwhelming."(Reddit)
Another adds:
"It is full size, with 300–350 built-in games, easy USB expansion, streaming, and superior controls compared to A1U. No comparison out of the box."(Reddit)
Verdict: Users appreciate ALU’s power and flexibility, while others in shared spaces find simpler Arcade1Up units more practical and engaging en masse.
Side-by-Side Summary
| Feature | AtGames Legends Ultimate | Arcade1Up Cabinets |
|---|---|---|
| Game Library | 300–350 built-in, expandable to thousands | 3–12 themed games, limited expansion |
| Cabinet Size & Build | Full-size (66"), solid MDF | ¾-scale, lightweight and compact |
| Controls | Joysticks, buttons, spinners, trackball | Basic joystick and buttons |
| Assembly | 30–60 mins, preassembled top | Quicker, full assembly required |
| Connectivity | Wi-Fi, streaming, USB/HDMI support | Minimal features |
| Best For | Deep retro fans, customization | Casual use, limited space, themed nostalgia |
Final Thoughts
The AtGames Legends Ultimate is a powerhouse cabinet—ideal for those seeking variety (300+ games), authentic controls, and expandable features. Perfect for a serious home arcade setup.
Arcade1Up, on the other hand, wins on charm and simplicity—great for smaller spaces or those craving themed cabinets with nostalgic flair.
It's a choice between depth and flexibility (ALU) versus simplicity and style (Arcade1Up). Match your pick to your space, budget, and play style—either way, you're bringing arcade history home.
🛒 Should You Buy the AtGames Legends Ultimate or Another Arcade?
If you’re on the fence, here’s a quick guide to help:
✅ Buy the Legends Ultimate if you want:
A full-sized arcade cabinet that feels authentic.
Access to 300+ built-in games plus the option to expand into the thousands.
Advanced features like Wi-Fi, streaming, and USB/HDMI connectivity.
High-quality controls with spinners and a trackball for a wide variety of titles.
A system that grows with you if you like modding and customization.
✅ Buy an Arcade1Up Cabinet if you want:
A smaller, lighter cabinet for tighter spaces.
A quick setup with minimal fuss.
Themed nostalgia (e.g., Pac-Man, Street Fighter, NBA Jam).
A more budget-friendly option.
A simple, plug-and-play arcade that doesn’t need extra expansion.
⭐ Final Tip
If you can only buy one cabinet, the Legends Ultimate is the more versatile and future-proof choice. But if you’re building a collection of themed arcades, Arcade1Up cabinets are fun, stylish, and more space-efficient.